Chapter 4-Burdens
Thoughts:
- Alcott's preaching thinly veiled in the form of Marmee really doesn't bother me. I know that it gets on some people's nerves (and I'm not very far into the book…perhaps I will dislike it later on). In fact, there are plenty of times where I think that Alcott has very valuable things to say, even for today's readers.
- "Meg was Amy's confidant and monitor, and by some strange attraction of opposites, Jo was gentle Beth's. To Jo alone did the shy children tell her thoughts; and over her big, harum-scarum sister, Beth unconsciously exercised more influence than any one in the family." I love this quote. Especially because I have seen this phenomenon so many times in real life.
- And the quote that made me laugh the most in this post? "'My only comfort', she said to Meg, with tears in her eyes, 'is that Mother doesn't take tucks in my dresses whenever I'm naughty, as Maria Parks' mother does. My dear, it's really dreadful; for sometimes she is so bad, her frock is up to her knees, and she can't come to school. When I think of this degerredation, I feel that I can bear even my flat nose and purple gown, with yellow sky-rockets on it.'"
Questions:
Whose burden do you think is the greatest to bear of the four sisters? I must say that I really do pity Meg, but what do you think?
What did you think of Marmee/Alcott's preaching in this chapter? Do you think it detracted from the story, or was it a useful addition?
Chapter 5-Being Neighborly
I dearly love this chapter. We finally get a good look at Laurie and there is a nice little adventure in the middle of the chapter. The story starts with Jo setting off on an adventure to try to talk to "The Laurence boy". She succeeds and even gains entrance to the elegant house. After a long, cozy chat with Laurie, who is recovering from a cold, she retires to the a lovely library, while Laurie has a doctor's appointment. There, to her shock, she meets the stern, foreboding Mr. Laurence, Laurie's grandfather who Jo is just a little afraid of. However, she makes a good impression on Laurie's grandfather, who likes her at once, and she stays to tea. All in all, this has to be one of the happiest chapters in the book.
Thoughts:
Thoughts:
- There is quite a bit of girl-boy friendships discussions throughout the chapter. I think it's quite obvious that Alcott knows that she is going to shock and ruffle feathers. Laurie pays Jo a very nice compliment, which Jo does not even know is a compliment. Afterwards, when Jo is telling about it, Meg says, "'I never saw such a girl! You don't know a compliment when you get it, said Meg with an air of a young lady who knew all about the matter. 'I think they are great nonsense, and I'll thank you not to be silly and spoil my fun. Laurie's a nice boy, and I like, him, and I won't have any sentimental stuff about compliments and such rubbish. We'll all be good to him, because he hasn't got any mother, and he may come over and see us, mayn't he, Marmee?'"
- "And, having pulled the boy's hair by way of a caress, Mr. Laurence walked on…" I think it is very interesting that Alcott took note of this. I'm quite sure that paternal interaction like this was the norm and I think it's very interesting that Alcott notices, and disapproves, of this.
- After reading about blanc mange in this chapter (and then reading the discussion in the comments on this blog), I decided to do some blanc mange research. I didn't find a good blanc mange recipe, but I did make panna cotta, which is basically the same thing-cream, sugar, gelatin, and then other add-ins. Basically a custard with gelatin. And it was very delicious! I made a grapefruit and vanilla bean panna cotta.
Questions:
Have you ever had blanc mange/something similar? If so, did you like it?
Chapter 6-Beth Finds the Palace Beautiful
This is the chapter that alternately makes me melancholic knowing that this won't last and happily cooing over Beth and Mr. Laurence's relationship. Beth discovers that there is a beautiful piano at the Laurence's, but she is far too timid to play it. Mr. Laurence gets wind of this and comes over to quietly encourage her to come and play the piano, assuring her, through Marmee, who he is ostensibly talking to, that she will not have to cross paths with any people. So Beth ventures over. But then it gets sweeter. Mr. Laurence actually gives Beth his dead little daughter's piano for her very own, a little bit of heartbreaking foreshadowing that only those of us who have read the book 8 million times will notice. I almost wish I didn't know what was coming. And the chapter closes with Beth and Mr. Laurence walking home hand in hand after Beth gives him her personal thanks. *Sniff* Excuse me while I leave to blow my nose.
 |
| Image from: Pinterest |
Thoughts:
- I often fall into the camp of people that think that Beth is terribly one-dimensional and too good for words. And then I get to this chapter and I can't help but completely understand Beth in this chapter, though my personality has never been like hers. I think this is the chapter that redeems Beth. She has a problem, overcomes it, and makes a new friend, all in about ten pages. What could be better?
- I am really wishing I had the time to read through Pilgrim's Progress (or that I had the attention span to read through what I remember as being a very, very dry book). The constant references are just a little bit confusing. I mean, the references aren't bad enough that this book makes no sense without prior knowledge of PP, but I think it would be helpful. Maybe some day…
Questions:
Do you think that this chapter makes Beth more understandable and easier to identify with?
Have any of you read Pilgrim's Progress and, if so, what did you think of it?
Whew! And that closes one of my longest posts! I'll be back tomorrow with more thoughts about Little Women. I am enjoying this book so much!
No comments:
Post a Comment