An Old Fashioned Girl is the story of Polly, a shy, smart, highly spirited girl. She goes to visit a friend, Fanny, who lives a cosseted life with her wild brother Tom, her whiny, spoiled little sister Maud, her distracted businessman father, her self-absorbed, hypochondriacal mother and her lonely grandmother who disapproves of the whole family. Into this scene full of ennui and dissipation comes a breath of fresh air in the form of young Polly. She, a country girl from a countercultural family that reminds me of the Marches, is shocked by the city life so full of problems and trouble in spite of the wealth. She is introduced to Polly's shallow friends and she begins to work change in the family and she begins to see the real sides of her hosts.
The book is spread over a time period of about 10 years. By the end, there is a charming suitor, Mr. Sidney, and Polly has grown in wisdom and maturity and has become an even more well-rounded character. Polly is living in a little apartment and keeping house for herself and giving music lessons to support her brother in college. Then the unthinkable happens-Polly and her family lose all of their money in some banking crises. And…well, you'll have to read this wonderful book to find out what happens!
The domestic descriptions are unbelievable cozy, particularly when Polly moves into her own house. It's one of the lovely bonuses of this book. I couldn't find the particular description that I love, so you'll just have to read the book and find it for yourself.
Even though Polly is a Victorianly good character, there is nothing saccharine or fake about her goodness. She has her struggles, very much like the March sisters of Little Women. She has troubles and setbacks just like all of us, but she has a loving family base that is helping her along as she sees new, tempting, strange things. The old-fashioned in the title is from when Fanny and her friends refer to Polly as "old-fashioned" and "little-girl-ish" because she doesn't behave the way Fanny and her friends do.
Polly's family is not portrayed as a demon-family, but simply one that has become distracted by worldly things and in the process has forgotten the family. Polly is simply there to remind them of the importance of each other. The books is not explicitly Christian, but there is that undertone, much like the undertone in Little Women. I think that also has a lot to do with the way that Polly and her family behave.
|Finished! (Does anybody else prop their books against|
their tea pot? It makes the perfect hands-free reading!
Polly reminds me of Meg March is so many ways. If L.M. Alcott were to write a story just about Meg on her own in a strange city, you would get this book. I've always identified with Meg in Little Women. I do not have that willful, passionate Jo March streak, goodness knows I'm not like saintly Beth and I hope to goodness I'm not like the spoiled, vain Amy. Meg's calm, practical nature, in spite on her own personal temptations resonated with me, which is part of the reason I identified with Polly.
The ultimate message of this story and the whole story in general are really timeless. There is nothing archaic or old-fashioned about the writing or the story. Louisa May Alcott did it again-she wrote another wonderful book about lovable characters that you are sure to remember for years after you read this book.